'No basis in reality': Expert turns tables on key Democrat claim against Trump's 'big, beautiful bill'
2025-06-20 12:00:59
Democrats in Washington, DC, The expert who spoke to Fox News Digital this week notes with a reconciliation package in Trump’s budget in Congress.
“The draft law does not reduce the benefits for anyone who has an income below the poverty line, and anyone working at least 20 hours a week and does not care about a child, and people from the Americans,” said Jim Agriste, the president and the founder of Adel.
“In other words, it cuts illegal immigrants who are not Americans and fraudulents. So the narration has no basis in reality. See, what has been going on since the medicaid program started? Have it be expanded, expanded and expanded. 3 % to 29 %.
The discounts were medical aid and reform The main adhesion point With the Democrats, who have combined data from two new reports from the Non -party Congress Budget Office (CBO) to support claims that approximately 14 million will lose coverage. The White House and the Republicans objected, as not all policy proposals that were actually evaluated in the Republicans ’legislation have been included, and many people will face insurance loss.
Instead, Republicans argue that their proposed reforms to implement work requirements, enhance eligibility and take strict measures against Medicaid for illegal immigrants maintain the program for those who really need it.
“I agree,” Dim. MP Yasmine Crocate He said in response to this To a CNN claim that the Republicans “want the poor to die” with discounts in medical aid.
I tell Agresti Fox News Digital that Medicaid discounts aim to get people out of poverty and waste.
“It sets some criteria down,” hey, if you want this, and you are not in poverty, you need to work. “You need to do something to improve your situation, which is what these programs are supposed to be, expel people of poverty, and not to adhere to them for eternity. So the whole idea is to make people work, and give them an incentive. Hey, if you want to do a better job in life, you want to cover this medical aid, then you must earn it. “
Independent Senator Bernie Sanders Claim The draft law is the “death penalty for the working class”, because it raises health insurance “payments for the poor.”
Agresti launched this “strange” claim.
“First of all, the big beautiful bill does not raise payments on anyone less than the poverty line,” he explained. “Now, for people who are above the poverty line, it requires states to charge at least somewhat Copayment, and it also reduces, in fact, Max Copayment from $ 100 per visit to $ 35 per visit.”
Agresti went on to clarify that under the current system, “people have only to curb their only to go to the doctor, emergency room or any other place without any joint payment, and they are not in poverty.”
“What ends up is that they waste a lot of money.” “It has been proven through the random control experiences, which is the golden standard for the analysis of social sciences, where you have people in the lottery system, and some people get the benefit, and some people do not do that, and what ends with you is that people who do not have to get skin in the game, abuse emergency rooms, and go there for its full nose, and make all these money, and there is nothing to improve their health. waste.”
“The facts of Mr. Agresti here are simply incorrect,” said Sanders Anna Bahr.
“Nearly half of all registered in ACA exchanges are Republicans,” the Sanders office added.
“But workers must earn at least $ 15,650 annually to qualify for tax credits on ACA-almost equal to the annual income of a full-time factor that earns the minimum federal wages.”
Sanders also referred to “CBO Estimates 16 million people will lose insurance as a result of the draft law that was passed at home and the Republicans who deny the distinguished tax credits from ACA. “
The Sanders office also reiterated that the draft law passed to the home is “a basic change” for the beneficiaries of Medicaid, and turns from my choice to mandatory.
Agresti replied: “While claiming that I am incorrect,” Sanders’ employees failed to provide one fact that BBB reduces health care for poor working Americans, “Agresti answered.
“It is particularly funny to cite expanded benefits in Obacare in this context, because people in poverty are not qualified for them,” Agresti continued. “After the” temporary “publishing process, which dates back to the Kofid era, will continue to have an income of up to 400 % of the Federal Poverty-or $ 150,600 for a five–qualified for this social welfare program, although they will get less.”
AGRESTI argued that the claim of “$ 35 is a maximum COPAY (for non -poor people)” hurts working families “not supported by research” that makes generalizations and only cited associations. “
“It is also studying commonly in mathematics in secondary schools, the causal association does not prove,” said Agristei.
“It seems that Mr. Agresti believes that a working family of four people earns only $ 32,150 annually does not deserve to help provide health care. Health care in the United States is more expensive than anywhere in the world. End health coverage of 16 million and increasing health care costs for millions will make it more expensive than working in obtaining care The health they need, even if Mr. Agresti does not agree on it. “
Agresti also faced a problem with the narration that discounts cannot be done to medicaid without cutting the benefits to the people who are entitled to.
Agresti said: “The government accountability office has developed amazing numbers, which will waste hundreds of billions of dollars annually.” “So, yes, some criteria to ensure that it does not happen is a wise idea. Unfortunately, there is a lot of the crime of white collars in this country, and this type of crime is the crime of white collars. It is not bound by a pistol, or by stealing or beating a person, which is its commission, and there is a huge amount of that.
“The big and beautiful draft law, again, seeks to curb this by setting standards to ensure that we are checking the income of people, and we check their assets. Many of these federal programs and government health care programs, and stop verify the assets. So you can be a winner of the share sitting on 3 million dollars in cash, and they still have very little income.
Holie said on Monday that he had not faced a problem with some changes in marquee on Madikid that their Republican counterparts wanted in the House of Representatives, including the most striking requirements of work, taking off illegal immigrants from the entitlements, waste, fraud and abuse of the program that serves tens of millions of Americans.
However, he pointed out that about 1.3 million Missouri depends on the Medicaid program and the Children’s Health Insurance Program (Chip), and he claimed that most of them were working.
“These are not people sitting around them, these are people working,” he said. “They are in Medicaid because they cannot afford private health insurance costs, and they do not get it in the job.”
“I just think it is wrong to go to these people and say,” Well, as you know, we know that you are doing your best, and we know that you are working hard, but we will prepare to reach health care. ”
Diana Stansi and Alex Miller of Fox News Digitter contributed to this report.
[og_img]
Post Comment