How a government app in India triggered a backlash over internet freedom

The report is taken from this week’s edition of CNBC’s ‘Inside India’ newsletter which brings you timely and insightful news and market commentary on the emerging economic powerhouse. Subscribe here.

The big story

It all started this Monday.

The Indian government has required phone makers to pre-load a state-run cybersecurity app with no option to disable it, and has required them to push it through software updates on phones.

On Tuesday, there was a backlash on social media and pressure from internet freedom activists, with the country’s main opposition party calling the app a “snooping app.”

On Wednesday, the government backed away from the mandate given to the Sanchar Saathi app, while defending it as a “citizen-centric tool that brings robust security features and fraud reporting capabilities directly to users’ smartphones.”

While the country has bowed to public pressure, this is not the first time the government has found itself in trouble over accusations of digital overreach, including compromising people’s privacy.

In 2023, security breaches were reported in a state-run coronavirus vaccination app, the introduction of which also raised privacy concerns. The Ministry of Health in the beginning He denied the allegationBut days later the country’s Minister of Information and Technology said Local media The root cause of the leak has been identified.

While internet freedom activists in the country welcomed the government’s move to revoke Sanchar Sathe’s mandate, they said the battle is far from over.

Nikhil Pahwa, a digital rights activist, told CNBC that given the amount of data leaked by the government and several previous data linkage mandates, “they are now unable to contain the fraud.”

Experts say government policies are often misdirected. If the government is serious about solving the problem of online fraud, “they need financial network controls, not a phone app,” said Mishi Chowdhury, a lawyer who specializes in online advocacy cases, referring to Sanchar Sathe.

She said the government instead needs to address pathways used for fraud such as SIM Swap, mule banking, fake loan applications, cross-border call centers and remote access applications.

according to Local media reportssmartphone makers and operating system providers claimed that there had been no prior industry consultation on pre-installation authorization.

Reuters I mentioned that apple It had resisted complying with the directive and planned to take its concerns about “security lapses” to authorities in New Delhi.

The Indian Telecom Department and the Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology did not respond to CNBC’s requests for comment.

In March, Elon Musk’s company X filed a lawsuit against the Indian government over New Delhi’s order to remove content from its platform. Setting that aside, the government in May he asked X to remove 8,000 accounts in the country, including those of international news organizations and high-profile users.

the platform It said the Indian state ordered the company to block another 2,355 accounts in July, including that of the Reuters news agency. Troubled waters, government to reject Give any New Block Order to X.

While efforts to restrict some accounts from operating in the country have been criticized by civil society and digital rights activists, an Indian court ruling that rejected X’s legal challenge against the government appears to have eased the issue of freedom of expression.

Governments around the world are grappling with “how to assert control over large, affiliated data sets held by private actors,” said Joe Jones, director of research and insights at the International Association of Privacy Professionals.

He added that while these regulations are mostly justified from the perspective of government-led action “to protect public safety and national security,” government access to data creates “privacy and cybersecurity concerns.”

Unlike China, the Internet and smartphone space in India is dominated by global companies. India represents one of Largest user bases For American technology giants such as dead and GoogleA. presents Growing consumer The market is for companies like Apple. Digital mandates by India are impacting global companies.

While Sanchar Sathi’s mandate has put the issue in the spotlight, another policy by India could put popular messaging app companies like Meta, which owns WhatsApp, in trouble.

Under the SIM-binding regulations, introduced last week, messaging services must be permanently linked to the SIM card associated with a device, making it impossible to use the app without the designated active SIM card. This policy aims to reduce cyber fraud.

“Instant messaging and calling app accounts continue to function even after the associated SIM card is removed, deactivated or moved abroad, enabling anonymous scams, remote ‘digital arrest’ scams and government impersonation calls using Indian numbers.” He said on monday.

Messaging app companies will also have to ensure that they log out of the web service periodically, after every 6 hours.

SIM tethering and forced periodic logouts can “cause material inconvenience and service disruption to ordinary users,” while offering “limited additional benefit against sophisticated fraud networks,” the Broadband India Forum, an industry body, said in a statement. Big tech companies like Google, Meta, Amazon and Samsung are part of the BIF.

The industry body also criticized the Department of Communications for issuing guidance with “far-reaching impact” with short timelines for implementation and without seeking public consultation or user impact assessment.

Chaudhary said SIM card linking is a poorly designed decision that will not solve the problem of online fraud but will “make citizens’ lives more difficult.”

Messaging services in India have been mandated to complete the SIM tethering implementation within 90 days. So far there are no signs of retreat on this front.

Top TV picks on CNBC

Sanjay Mathur, ANZ Bank’s chief economist for India and Southeast Asia, said he expects the Reserve Bank of India to cut interest rates by 25 basis points in December despite strong second-quarter GDP data.

Vishrut Rana, Asia-Pacific economist at S&P Global Ratings, said he expects India to achieve its GDP target of $5 trillion in 2028, beating International Monetary Fund estimates.

Gautam Shahi of Dua Co He said that depending on how the penalties are calculated, Apple, which potentially faces fines of up to $38 billion in the antitrust case in India, could end up paying much less than it feared.

The economy grew faster than expected from July to September. In a quarter partly affected by 50% US tariffs, the Indian economy It grew faster than expected rose 8.2% year-on-year in the quarter ended September, beating estimates.

Russian President Vladimir Putin in India: During the two-day visit, the two countries Set to extend Their strategic and trade relations are likely to deepen cooperation in the field of defense and civil nuclear energy.

Decreased industrial output. Industrial production grew only 0.4% in October Lowest level in 14 months With a decline in manufacturing sector production, while mining activity and electricity production decreased by 1.8% and 6.9%, respectively.

India Stylish 50’s It rose 0.11% on Thursday as of 2:50 pm local time, while the BSE Sensex was trading flat. The Nifty has gained nearly 10% so far this year.

Indian Thursday rupee It opened trading at a new low of 90.4 to the dollar, marking a record low for the third day in a row.

The yield on India’s benchmark 10-year government bond was almost flat at 6.535%.

– The light of the wisdom of Muhammad Ali

Coming

December 5: Reserve Bank of India monetary policy meeting

December 8: Wakefit Innovations IPO opens

December 10: Nephrocare Health Services IPO opens

Every weekday, CNBC’s ‘Inside India’ news show brings you news and market commentary on powerful emerging companies and the people behind their rise. Stream the show live on YouTube and catch highlights here.

Show times:

we: Sunday-Thursday, 23:00-0000 ET
Asia: Monday to Friday, 11:00-12:00 Singapore/Hong Kong time, 08:30-09:30 India time
Europe: Monday to Friday, 0500-06:00 CET