Former federal official explains isolation of Charlie Kirk murder suspect

OREM, Utah — A former federal corrections official says a Utah prison is holding Tyler Robinson, the man accused of assassination Turning Point USA founder Charlie Kirk, It would be reckless not to treat him differently from other prisoners, and to prescribe a strict and heightened security regime aimed at keeping him and others safe.

“Someone like this, like Charlie Kirk’s alleged killer, is in very different circumstances than he was at previous times in his life,” Judy Garrett told Fox News.

“So, while he may or may not have shown any inclination toward certain behaviors, he may be interested in engaging in those behaviors now. … Any guardian of someone like this would be remiss in not treating him very differently from most other people in his population.”

Garrett, the former assistant director of the Bureau of Prisons, explained Prisoner isolation Not necessarily a punishment

What is Tyler Robinson’s defensive strategy? Experts weigh accused Charlie Kirk as murderer

Tyler Robinson actually appears in a Utah court on September 16, 2025 to face charges in the assassination of Charlie Kirk. (Utah state courts)

“The concept of isolating prisoners and keeping them away from the general population is either to protect them or to protect others,” she said.

Garrett added that separations can stem from safety concerns, risks of self-harm, or threats from others within the facility.

She added: “There are certainly times when someone is isolated for punishment, although the day-to-day circumstances are not much different between someone who is isolated for discipline or for ‘protection.’

Charlie Kirk, the murder suspect, remains in a special housing unit despite a completed mental evaluation

Booking photos of Tyler Robinson, 22, the suspect in the assassination of Turning Point USA founder Charlie Kirk in Utah. (Utah Governor Spencer Cox)

For Robinson and others under tight supervision, almost everything is brought to them.

“When someone is removed from the general population, everything flips,” Garrett said. “So they are served…and their meals are brought to their cell. The doctor comes to their cell. The idea is that you want to get someone out of their cell as few times as possible, because doing that requires a lot of staff resources.”

Despite the term “solitary confinement,” Garrett said these inmates are “not isolated from people,” because staff enter frequently to provide meals, medical care and other services.

Robinson, who was seen only once via video by the public in his first court appearance, was wearing what officials described as a “suicide outfit,” though authorities have not confirmed his current surveillance status.

Garrett said the precaution fits standard practice.

“If you’re on suicide watch, you want someone watching you every 15 minutes,” Garrett explained.

Utah prosecutors are preparing a potential death penalty case against Charlie Kirk suspect Tyler James Robinson

An enhanced police presence, including snipers on rooftops, surrounded the Utah County Justice Center in Provo, Utah, on September 16, 2025, as Tyler Robinson appeared in court to face charges in the murder of Charlie Kirk. (Derek Schock for Fox News Digital)

She noted that housing these prisoners alone, although an “uncomfortable life,” could be “necessary and very wise” to prevent harm to themselves or others.

Even with the restrictions, Garrett said inmates maintain contact with attorneys and, to a lesser extent, family.

“In terms of communicating with the outside, he is certainly allowed to communicate with his lawyer,” she explained, adding that family calls will likely be limited because “the phone must be brought to him.”

Garrett added that surveillance remains tight.

“Prisoners’ communications outside of communications with lawyers are certainly always monitored,” she said.

When asked what Robinson’s pretrial routine might look like, Garrett described what a typical day might look like.

“I imagine he is confined to his cell for 23 hours or so a day. He will be allowed out for recreation, which may or may not be outside. I don’t imagine he is allowed to mingle with other inmates for safety and security reasons.”

Charlie Kirk, the suspected murder suspect, is under “special observation” in custody and is being kept in a separate housing unit

Garrett added that meals, showers and legal visits all take place under guard or within the cell itself.

Solitary confinement reforms have sparked intense debate over the past decade, Garrett said.

“Just the terminology…is a misnomer,” she said. “These people are not isolated from others, nor are they in an isolated environment.”

Reformers push for more human contact; Correctional officers argue the tool is essential for safety. She pointed to New York’s HALT law, which limits solitary confinement, as an example of stoking tensions with employees.

Garrett stressed that humane treatment is not driven by compassion, but rather by the need to ensure the safety of inmates.

“More importantly, 96, 7, 8, 9 percent of them come back into the community at some point,” she said. “If you mistreat people in prison, they will mistreat someone else…so it is in everyone’s interest to operate institutions that are humane.”

Even in high-security or death row units, “these people…don’t have a lot to lose,” she said, so extreme caution protects staff and inmates alike.

Click here to download the FOX NEWS app

Robinson is Accused of fatal shooting Kirk during a campus event at Utah Valley University on Sept. 10. The authorities described the incident as a targeted assassination.

Later the same day, Robinson was arrested St. George after making statements to his parents, romantic partner and friends that admitted or implied his involvement, according to court documents.

He now faces seven charges, including first-degree murder, which carries a possible death penalty, along with felony charges of discharging a firearm, obstruction of justice, and witness tampering. He has not yet filed a petition.

Stephenie Price covers crime, including missing persons, homicides and immigrant crimes. Send story tips to stepheny.price@fox.com.